Wednesday, May 23, 2012

"MBA vs PhD" - Career advise from a Harvard Economics Professor

From the link:

A blog reader asks for advice:

Hello Professor Mankiw,
I am a second-year economics student at the University of California, Davis. I was wondering if you could share your opinion on the career options provided by a Ph.D in economics compared to those of an M.B.A., particularly with regards to earning potential. Historically I have preferred business school for its good "bang for the buck," but lately I have thought that immediate graduate school might be my best option, given the relative strengths and weaknesses of my track record (i.e.,stronger academics than work experience). Could you tell me which option you would prefer in my position? You don't have to make any sort of absolute, unequivocal statement, but I appreciate any advice you can offer. Thank you very much for your time.
[name withheld]

I believe that from a purely financial standpoint, an MBA is a better investment than a PhD. An MBA is only a two-year program, whereas a PhD is typically four to six years. The extra time for a PhD probably not yield the extra income needed to make it a good investment of your time. A typical Harvard MBA gets a starting salary a bit over $100K; the typical econ PhD does not start much higher than that.

But the issue is not entirely pecuniary. The question you should be asking yourself is what kind of job you want to have when you conclude your education. A PhD makes sense if you want to consider the possibility of being an academic. You may pursue a PhD and then decide along the way to pursue a different path than being a professor. That is okay: Many PhD students leave for the private sector when they are done with their degrees, and they get very good jobs there. But if you are sure from the beginning that you want some kind of private-sector job, then the MBA is probably the better route.


  1. Thanks for sharing information….
    Give right direction to your career while selecting the professional courses. We are providing PhD admissions in UGC recognized Indian Universities and maximum support to complete this doctorate program.
    PhD In Management.

  2. Good blog post, Water should not be a misfortune at any rate since water is imperative for the human. This examination should be authentic and learn more in time with the objective that we can save more water. The decision of the commission is measurable and demonstrating incredible energy for this examination.

  3. Advancing is the principal technique to import the things. You have to set everything according to the overall public and it is an incredible way. You in like manner give the centrality of the advancing and about the estimation of this.

  4. Good site, These tips are so group for me since I am worried over my blog and how to manage this blog. This supports me an extensive measure and you fill my heart with happiness.

  5. Good post. Understudies are exhausted when they think about persistently and this sort of action is vital for the understudies but you can go here to manage your educational task. When you take a stab at something one of a kind for understudies it implies that understudies require this movement.

  6. There some very impressive points in your blog. I heard heaps of things about the Italy and need to go in this nation but you can visit website for quality task. Italy is the great place for the travel industry and each can appreciate the delightful things of this nation.